“August” is concerning the finish of a teenage summer season romance, however this connection is sophisticated by the truth that the tune’s topic is already dedicated to a different. On this method, whereas the observe facilities across the finish of a seasonal fling, it is wistfulness partly stems from the thought of being somebody’s second alternative. Whereas being the “different girl” has a unfavorable connotation, Taylor Swift complicates this concept by demonstrating the genuineness of August’s emotions.
That is conveyed in traces resembling “August sipped away like a bottle of wine / ‘Trigger you had been by no means mine,” which reveals the tenuous connection between James and August by evaluating the longevity of their relationship to a wine bottle and referencing his dedication to a different. “Again once I was livin’ for the hope of all of it” is among the most putting lyrics of “august,” because it demonstrates the earnestness of the narrator’s emotions whereas signifying her understanding of the connection’s inevitable finish.
Swift feedback on these earnest emotions and the thought of being the “different girl” within the documentary “Folklore: The Lengthy Pond Studio Session,” saying, “So the concept that there’s some, like, some unhealthy, villain woman in any kind of state of affairs who, like, takes your man is definitely a complete delusion as a result of that is not often the case in any respect. Like, everyone has emotions and needs to be seen and liked, identical to Augustine — that is all she needed was love.”